Galatians 5.11: Evidence of an Early Law-observant Mission by Paul?
نویسنده
چکیده
Galatians . refers to Paul ‘proclaiming circumcision’—a proposition that he is concerned to refute because he constructs two compact but powerful inferences designed to falsify it. One argues from present persecution, the other from the cross. Following a precise reconstruction of these it can be shown that the three main previous interpretations of the reference of Paul’s ‘proclamation of circumcision’ are dubious, whether in terms of a blatantly false charge by opponents, a phase in Paul’s pre-Christian Jewish life, or an occasional apostolic mission to Jews. A fourth, embarrassing reading is more likely, especially when other comparable missionary work is considered. Early on Paul proclaimed a fully law-observant gospel to pagans that included circumcision, but then later revised his praxis.
منابع مشابه
The New Perspective(s) on Paul and Its Implication for Ethics and Mission
In this article the New Perspectives1 on Paul and its implication for Pauline ethics will be discussed as well as the relationship it has to the understanding of the missionary dynamics in Paul. The article begins with the history of the development of the New Perspectives on Paul and continues by exploring James Dunn’s contribution to the understanding of the controversy in the Letter to the G...
متن کاملDeviance or acceptable difference : Observance of the Law in Romans 14 – 15 and Dialogue with Trypho 47
How to cite this article: Roberts, R.D., 2012, ‘Deviance or acceptable difference: Observance of the Law in Romans 14–15 and Dialogue with Trypho 47’, HTS Teologiese Studies/ Theological Studies 68(1), Art. #1015, 10 pages. http:// dx.doi.org/10.4102/hts. v68i1.1015 Utilising the symbolic interactionist study of deviance, this article compares the treatment of Law-observant Christ-followers in ...
متن کاملWho Were Paul's Opponents in Galatia?
Paul's opponents in Galatia are central to the argument of Galatians because the epistle is essentially a response to their threat to the churches of Galatia. Therefore it is not surprising to see that the opponents are mentioned in every chapter (1:6-9; 2:4-5; 3:1; 4:17; 5:10, 12; 6:12-13). Conservative scholars have historically assumed that these foes were Judaizers and have interpreted the ...
متن کاملGalatians 3:19-20: a Crux Interpretum for Paul's View of the Law*
H. J. Schoeps begins his chapter on "Paul's Teaching about the Law" in his highly acclaimed work, Paul: The Theology of the Apostle in the Light of Jewish Religious History, with the remark that "the Pauline understanding of the law [is] the most intricate doctrinal issue in his theology." It deserves this accolade, according to Peter Stuhlmacher, "not only because Paul's terminology is highly ...
متن کاملIdentity Claims, Texts, Rome and Galatians
This contribution explores the interplay between Paul’s use of the Scriptures of Israel and the imperial setting in claims about Abraham and the negotiation of identity in the Galatians letter. The letter, from Paul’s perspective, is testimony to fierce contestation of identity and finds him engaged in describing, defining and scripting insiders and outsiders in and around the community. In his...
متن کامل